Restaurant review -Why do we still like Sabir’s Hotel!

Chandni Chowk is that part of Kolkata which I would frequent during my Presidency College days. There’s nothing in electronics that one can’t get hold of in Chandni market. Looking at the crowd this Friday afternoon, I easily concluded that despite a booming e-commerce sector, the market had neither lost its charm nor appeal. Situated in one such lane is the age old Sabir’s Hotel. Way back in the seventies, when my father was a post graduate student in Calcutta University, this was a favorite eating out joint for them as well. No fine dining restaurant could get my husband so excited as going to this restaurant. That’s what Sabir’s stands for – a walk down memory lane.

First floor of Sabir’s

Ambiance – Someone frequenting fine dining, classy and five star restaurants would be appalled at the almost non existent ambiance of this joint. They have two floors. The ground floor is more of a place to eat for singles and friends. Th first floor is the family restaurant. The air conditioned portion of the restaurant is currently under renovation. They have extended the non ac part of the first floor in two portions. Each portion also have three cabin sized rooms with curtains. The seating arrangement is that of typical chairs and tables. Floors are generally dirty. The cutlery is old world. The hygiene of the restaurant is definitely dubious. Lighting is standard. No fancy lights or music here. But the balcony on the first floor gives a beautiful view of the busy market and the gets one acquainted with the experience of old Calcutta.


The old world ambience

Food – If there’s anything Sabir is still known for, it is their food. They serve the highly renowned mutton rezala, the taste of which is still irreplaceable. Infact I was quite amused to find them advertising this on their menu card and boards. Items on the menu are limited and one would do good to stick by the dishes Sabir is famous for. We tried out Green salad,Tandoori roti, Mutton Rezala, Chicken bharta, Firni, Cold Drinks and Tea. This place serves the best Tandoori roti in the city – the softness stays the same even after the roti gets cold. Mutton rezala is outstanding as always – the mutton piece literally melts in the mouth. I decided to give Chicken bharta a try by skipping the usual chicken chap and I was delighted with the result. Bharta had four pieces of boneless chicken and a full boiled egg cut into two. It tasted heavenly with roti. Firni was good and tea was decent. Salad was of the standard type. The outlet serves dishes dipped in ghee/butter/oil yet it is easily digestible. Looking at the restaurant, it is evident that hygiene is not one of their priorities but the quality and taste of the food overshadows every other aspect.

Part of the menu

Service – The restaurant has carried on with the typical non smiling and business like  attitude  of staffs. They wouldn’t bother recommending any dish because they are sure of the fact that if one has come this far, they would know what to order. So, they hand over the menu card, take the order, serve the food in minutes and clear the table immediately after one has had the last bite. So while service is very fast, there’s nothing much to expect in terms of courtesy and warmth. Yet I would say they are good for their efficiency.

The Chandelier

Pricing – Other than food, this is the parameter that goes hugely in favor of this outlet. They are very moderately priced. For the quality and quantity of portions served, the pricing is completely affordable. For one cold drink, one tea, one salad, one rezala, one bharta, four rotis and one firni, we ended up paying a meager sum of Rs. 571 only including GST.

Menu and pricing

My rating across various parameters would be –

Ambiance – 2.5

Food – 4.5

Service – 3

Pricing – 5

Overall – 3.8

Sabir is old world charm. There’s nothing fancy or glittery about this place. The only reason why people still choose to flock to this place in huge numbers is because of the food and nostalgia. Please visit this place if you would love to see what Calcutta used to be long back. Just a word of advice – it is better to try out dishes they are famous for else one might end up getting disappointed. Like roti is always recommended compared to biriyani and the rezala here is definitely a must have item.

Link to the review on TripAdvisor is

Sabir's Restaurant Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato

Author: Sonia Chatterjee Banerjee

Welcome to my page. Here's a sneak peak into my life. Born in Bengal,my obsession with chemistry got me seeking admission into the prestigious Presidency College, Kolkata followed by a masters degree from Delhi University. Loathing monotony in the field of research, I joined the corporate world in Bangalore. Two years later ,I ended up at a Business school to pursue MBA. Campus recruitment landed me a Branch Manager's profile with a top private sector bank, despite having studied nil finance papers in my specialization. Five years of Mysore life saw me switching banks and I moved back to Bangalore to head yet another bank branch. Always aspiring to be my own boss, an extended maternity break drove me to finally get back to my passion of writing. Sonia's musings is an attempt let out pent-up emotions through words hoping to resonate with the emotions of my readers in the journey. Married to a doctor, there are four things that I am crazy about - books, food, travel and my two plus year old ubercute son - in no particular order though.

One thought on “Restaurant review -Why do we still like Sabir’s Hotel!”

  1. Mr. Ghosh, since you have decided to go personal on the comment section, let me tell you my thoughts on your comment. Yes I am a blogger and proudly so. To add a background to this, my last assignment has been as a senior branch head with India’s top most private bank. I chose this profession and if you think of it so low, why bother to even comment? Secondly, my write up is a reflection of my experience and if I had a good experience, I would write so. You seem to have copied the non existent ambience bit from my blog as well. Just because you had a bad biriyani experience does not mean I need to have a bad roti-rezala experience. Thirdly, I write about a range of categories, food being one of them. At no point, have I claimed to be a food expert. You need to re read the about me section well I guess. Lastly, if you know how to check categories, go and see the restaurants mentioned there. It’s a mix of old and new. I’m sure you are aware of the vintage of Kabuliwala and jw kitchen since you seem to be the food expert here. Before you try to demean anyone for the hard work they put in to their job, better do your homework right by spending some time on their profile and write ups. I haven’t invited you to my page. Stay off if it bothers you so much but next time if you disagree, learn to frame your sentences better before getting personal. I stick by my review of every single write up on my page.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s